Introduction: This morning, I'd like to begin with a seemingly straightforward question: What is a documentary filmmaker? It sounds simple enough, but upon deeper reflection, the answer is filled with complexities and contradictions.
Capturing Real Life? A documentary filmmaker is someone who captures real life and transforms it into an enlightening experience for the audience. But what does "capturing real life" entail? If a camera crew followed you for weeks, would it truly capture your real life? In our everyday lives, there’s no script, no performance, and no fabrication. Or is there?
The Script of Reality Consider this: I’m reading this keynote address right now. After this, I’ll interact with some of you, exchanging remarks. Is this real life? When we recount personal stories, do we embellish, flatter ourselves, or omit details? Even in documentaries, the majority are scripted to some extent. For instance, the Oscar-winning "Icarus" had four credited screenwriters, more than most feature films. Editing in documentaries also holds immense power to shape, amplify, or distort reality.
Performances and Reenactments Documentary filmmakers typically don’t use actors, though this is debatable. Joshua Oppenheimer’s "The Act of Killing" features an elderly Indonesian man reenacting scenes from a past massacre. This staged premise allowed Oppenheimer to uncover a deeper truth about the past. Performance, inherently part of human nature, becomes even more complex when a camera is involved.
The Gray Area of Fabrication I once served on a film festival jury with Barbara Kopple, a two-time Oscar-winning documentarian. She pointed out a film she didn’t trust, saying the filmmaker sent someone on a contrived journey just to make the film. The audience can often sense such fabrications.
Documentary Filmmaker as Journalist Documentary filmmakers share the journalist’s quest for truth. They investigate and present facts, often putting themselves at great risk. Matt Heinemann’s "Cartel Land" immersively documents the US/Mexico drug war, trusting the viewer to draw conclusions from what they observe.
Documentary Filmmaker as Historian Like historians, documentarians like Claude Lanzmann and Frederick Wiseman meticulously gather and present real stories, offering raw materials for us to understand our world. Wiseman’s films, free from narration, let viewers explore the inner workings of institutions.
Documentary Filmmaker as Therapist These filmmakers, such as those behind "Life, Animated" and "Murderball," help us understand human reactions and challenges, finding universal lessons in personal struggles.
Documentary Filmmaker as Political Activist Filmmakers like Michael Moore use documentaries to advocate for causes, combining personal viewpoints with passionate pleas for justice.
Documentary Filmmaker as Poet Werner Herzog, who describes himself as a poet rather than a historian, creates films that evoke deep feelings and ethereal truths, focusing on the lyrical and inscrutable aspects of human experience.
Conclusion: Documentary filmmakers embody the determination of journalists, the insights of historians, the empathy of therapists, the passion of activists, and the creativity of poets. They are not stenographers or publicists; their films are not mere records but carefully crafted narratives that challenge and enlighten us. In a time when truth is under siege, the role of documentary filmmakers is more crucial than ever.
By Sal Framondi,
CEO/Founder, OPPRIME.tv
Producer, Black Filmmakers Matter
Black Filmmakers Matter celebrates the diverse voices and narratives of black filmmakers, offering a dynamic hub where every story finds its voice. Partnering with OPPRIME.tv, a leading video-on-demand platform, we empower independent filmmakers to reach a global audience. Our collaboration prioritizes film promotion and exposure, fostering impactful social and cultural discourse. Join us as we honor the creativity and resilience of filmmakers, navigating distribution challenges to achieve success.
Video-on-Demand: www.opprime.tv
Visit our filmmaker resource page: www.opprimetv.co